Tuesday, February 28, 2006


* The world will never forget that :
the penultimate step towards Adolf Hitler gaining complete control over the destiny of Germany were taken on the night of
27th February 1933 when the Reichstag (German Parliament) was destroyed by fire. The fire was almost certainly planned by the Nazis,
Goebbels and Goering in particular. A Dutch communist, Marinus van der Lubbe, was made scapegoat for the fire, but the main outcome was
that Hitler was given an excuse to have all the Communist deputies of the Reichstag arrested.
* The world will never forget that :
the coach S-6 of the Sabarmati Express Train was set on fire at Godhra Station on 27th February 2002, Till today, the truth of this fire which
killed 59 people, has not been established. That night, a high level meeting was held in Gandhinagar. People who have spoken against this
meeting have either been killed or been punished. The world wants to know what transpired at that meeting and why so many innocent people
were killed in Gujarat in the days and months that followed.
* The world will never forget that :
in the Social Science Textbooks of Gujarat State, Hitler is eulogized. The Holocaust is conveniently forgotten….it seems as though the
extermination of six millions of Jews just did not take place.

(An Austrian Court has convicted British historian David Irving for denying the Holocaust. He has been charged under law that defines
denial of the holocaust as a crime. Many European Democracies including France and Germany have similar laws that protect the
memory of the Holocaust from any kind of questioning. Such laws derive legitimacy from the understanding that denial of the Holocaust
is only the first step before justifying a crime unparallel in History - from THE TIMES OF INDIA editorial, 27th FEBRUARY 2006).
* The world will never forget that :
thousands of the victims of the Gujarat Carnage still wait for justice. The Best Bakery Case Judgment has come as a ray of hope….there are many
victims who eagerly wait more of such Judgments.
* The world will never forget 27th February 2002 and its aftermath

Just “not forgetting” does not help…… Act now and together, to ensure that such acts are never repeated in the History of Mankind – very specially that JUSTICE Triumphs and TRUTH is Vindicated in Gujarat !

Tuesday, February 21, 2006


By Fr. Cedric Prakash s.j

The widely circulated daily newspaper from Gujarat “ Sandesh” screened banner headlines on Sunday 5th February, “Missionario Samay Murari Bapuno Dhrujaro”(Murari Bapu attacks missionaries).The full length article contains all kinds of expletives and allegations against the Christians …It is the same Murari Bapu (a well known Hindu preacher with the mass following in Gujarat), who more than one and a half years ago, had suggested that Subir the tiny village in a remote area of the Dangs district should be the venue of a Shabri Kumbh.

That Murari Bapu makes such statements against the Christians is not totally unexpected from someone who has also become the poster boy of Hindu fundamentalists and fascist forces. Murari Bapu is just one of the star attractions at the Shabri Kumbh which will take place in the Dangs district from February 11 – 13, 2006; the others who are lined up are the whole range of the Hindutva shouting brigade: all shades of politicians, “sants” and others. Their website still loudly proclaims that more than five lakhs are going to gather for this Kumbh Mela. How many will ultimately turn up is any one’s guess. The crude fact is that even if just fifty percent of their estimated numbers come in, it will still overwhelm the tiny population of one lakh eighty thousand (the vast majority being tribals)who inhabit the Dangs.

The Dangs is a protected forest area; its beautiful sylvan surroundings with vast tracts of virgin forests, easily make it the envy of many other hill stations. However, the massive preparations for this Shabri Kumbh has resulted in the destruction of thousands of trees and made way to “development” (in terms of townships and roads) thanks to the massive amounts of funds being poured in by the Government of Gujarat. For an ordinary tribal who has no access to clean drinking water, primary health care or quality primary education, this massive showcasing of “material development” has left him dumb founded. Whilst some naturally see this as “progress” the vast majority really do not know how to react to this situation.

For the less than ten percent, who are Christians (some of them have been Christians for several generations) the onslaught which has already taken place by this Kumbh Mela is both intimidating and frightening. For several months now, sadhus in the guise of mendicants have been doing the rounds in their villages terrorizing them to give up Christianity and to participate whole heartedly in the Kumbh mela. What will actually happen during the days of the Kumbh is left to be seen. The “partakes” (pamphlets) distributed by fundamentalists organizations are obviously to raise the bogey of conversions and desperately calls for a “Ghar vapasi” (return to Hinduism) during the Shabri Kumbh. Last week, the Gujarat Government “told” the organizers that they should not have the reconversion programme as part of the kumbh meal’s farcical order in a drama in which they are totally involved!

At this juncture, the Gujarat Government is on the receiving end with notices to it from the Supreme Court, the National Human Rights Commission and several human rights organizations and individuals from all over. However, whilst all are assured that there will be absolutely “no problem” during the days of the Kumbh Mela ( actually everyone is clear that in the preparations and during the days of the Shabri Kumbh, there will be no physical attacks on Christians & Christian institutions.) the bare truth, however, is that the damage is already done. The vicious hate propaganda unleashed by communal forces with direct connivance with the Gujarat Government has helped the ugly head of communalism to bear its fangs in Gujarat once again.

Some days ago a Special Secretary from the Home Ministry of the Central Government, Mr. A.K.Mitra was sent to the Dangs to investigate matters. It is significant that the Catholic Church which has five well established and recognized institutions there, were not sent a letter of invitation to interact with Mr. Mitra. A telephonic call from the P.A to the Collector at the nth hour to the Religious Sisters, who run the Deep Darshan School, Ahwa, ensured some cosmetic presence. However the fundamentalist forces had their full complement of people including some “local Christians” who were all praise for the Kumbh mela and for the district administration! So much for people getting converted!

On Sunday Feb 5th, the Home Minister of Gujarat. Mr. Amit Shah had a round of meetings in the Dangs with regard to the preparations for the Kumbh mela. Very obviously, his assurances to the Christian delegations was that nothing will happen during the days of the mela, that police will be posted everywhere and that everyone’s cooperation is needed for the success of the Kumbh.

But the Home Minister of Gujarat is unable to answer are the following questions:

• Why are those who are indulging in hate propaganda against the Christians not being prosecuted?

• Why are the rules to govern the Freedom of Religion Act (2003) of the Gujarat Government not being framed? (It was enacted to prevent “forced conversions”)

• Why is the Gujarat Government patronizing the Shabri Kumbh and indulging in massive spending to create all kinds of infrastructure?

• What is being done to preserve the traditions, cultures of the the Adivasis of the Dangs, - in fact, their identity?

•How is the ecological destruction and the environmental degradation that is taking place in the Dangs being addressed?

The Gujarat Government is unable to answer any of these questions: the Kumbh mela will go on as planned with all the fanfare and the necessary rhetoric which has been so much part of the Modi Government… this time against the Christian minority !. The Central Government should act expeditiously and decisively. Until then it is ground zero, not merely for the adivasis of the Dangs but for the people of India…!

Dangs : Hindutva’s Last Gasp ?

By Fr. Cedric Prakash sj

The fascist and fundamentalist forces of the Hindutva Brigade were at their venomous best again ! For three days (from February 11 th to 13 th 2006), they spewed vitriol and hate against Christian Missionaries and their activities. From Narendra Modi to Morari Bapu to Togadia to lesser known icons of Hindutva, they tried to outdo each other in Christian bashing. In doing so, they proved just one point and their lie was nailed….that the Shabri Kumbh Mela that was held in Subir in the Dangs District of Gujarat had nothing to do with Hinduism, in the right sense of the word, but everything to do about creating communal discord. It had nothing to do with religion, but everything to do about politics.

The people did come in droves. Huge numbers brought in by trucks and buses from the BJP-ruled states of Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Jharkhand and Chattisgarh. When journalists spoke to some of the so called “pilgrims”, many of them had no idea why they had come; in fact, most of them said that they were enjoying a good picnic ! After all, it was the largesse of their respective Governments that provided them with everything from travel to food. The host, the Government of Gujarat spared no efforts in their year dedicated to the “Year of Tourism”. The mantra was clear….”if foreigners do not want to come to Gujarat, let’s import people, by hook or by crook from those States ruled by us !”. For good measure, the Shabri Kumbh did have some representatives from the World Council of Ethnic Religions, but this strategy too, misfired, when one of the delegates who began his speech with “Allah-hu-Akbar” was shouted down and one of the organizers insisted that he say “Jai Sri Ram”.

The opening salvo was fired by none other than Narendra Modi, the Chief Minister of Gujarat, who is doing everything in his power to make Gujarat a “Hindu” State. In a fiery outburst in his acerbic tongue, Modi lashed out against the Missionaries, warning them of severe repercussions if conversions continued. “It is my Constitutional duty to prevent conversions” he thundered, conveniently forgetting that he had abdicated his Constitutional responsibility when in 2002 hundreds of Muslims were slaughtered in the towns and villages of Gujarat; and that even today, in the State he administers, the minorities, dalits, adivasis and women are at the receiving end. His viciousness was easily lapped up by the vernacular media and one of them, the Sandesh, screamed banner headlines in its edition of Sunday 12th February, that the Shabri Kumbh will bring an end to conversions to Christianity. Not to be outdone by Modi, Morari Bapu, the Hindu Kathakar of Gujarat, used the Bible and the Vatican in his tirade against the Christians. He even quoted “Scripture” saying that “according to the Gospel of St. Luke, Christ forbade conversions and that “it is hypocrisy not to follow what you preach !”. A classic example of how Scripture can be turned and twisted to suit ones ideology. Morari Bapu continued saying that “if the Vatican can send plane-loads to convert India , we definitely have to respond fittingly”. Togadia went a step further and warned the Christians that if they did not give up converting, they would go and do a Bharatiyakaran of the Vatican City .

Togadia, the International General Secretary of the Vishwa Hindu Parishad, was predictable in his style, lashing out at Christians and other minorities, but then, in his scheme of things, he also felt that the Hindus and the Christians had to get together to counter Jehad and the likes of Osama Bin Laden. However, he went on to say, that before this grand alliance can materialize, the Vatican has to give up conversions in India , if not, the Vatican itself will be Hinduized.

The RSS Supremo, K. S. Sudarshan, boldly announced a new strategy to ensue that India dominated the world by the year 2011. The strategy named Bharitiyakaran, is to Indianize the seventeen crore Muslims and the three crore Christians who live in India . His message was amply clear “ since we cannot throw the Muslims and Christians into the sea, we have to “Indianize” them “. However, when asked by the media Sudarshan was unable to define what “being Indian” meant and whether to be Indian was also to be Hindu and if one has to be Hindu, to which rung of the caste hierarchy one necessarily need belong.

The Shabri Kumbh Mela was significant in the way the protagonists of the Sangh Parivar did their best to woo the tribals. They spelt out one issue loud and clear…..that the tribals would only be called vanvasis (forest dwellers) and not adivasis (original inhabitants of the land). Very cleverly, Sudarshan asserted “for vanvasis, we have to tell them that they are part of the extended Hindu family”.

In their overzealousness to present Hinduism to the adivasis, sadhu after sadhu criticized the caste-system and felt that it was a deviation that needed to be amended. They also made efforts to say that the status of women has to change in Hinduism because after all, in most tribal societies, there is a greater gender-equity. In unfolding the strategy for Bharatiyakaran Sudarshan also exhorted the sadhus and the cadres of the Sangh “to work quietly, to communicate with the poor and the tribals in their tongue, live with them and help them with health and food !”.

The three day mela also passed several resolutions, one of them is that the Centre should enact a law to prevent conversions specially in the tribals areas. It is ironical though, that on March 26th 2003, the Government of Gujarat unanimously passed the “Gujarat Freedom of Religion Act 2003”. However, almost three years down the road, the Government of Gujarat has not been able to frame the rules which are mandatory to guide the implementation of this draconian Act. On Christmas Day 2005, when the Home Minister was confronted on a public debate on TV, he was unable to offer an explanation as to why these rules were not yet framed. However, this terrible law is allowed to exist like a Damocles sword, misused by lower officials, yet without the possibility of it being challenged legally.

The Shabri Kumbh Mela is now over. The Chief Minister of Gujarat Narendra Modi profusely thanked the NGOs and Human Rights Activists for giving it the media coverage which it might not have otherwise got. The bare truth is, were it not for the NGOs, Human Rights Activists, and a whole movement of civil society, who challenged the sinister game-plan of this mela, the end result would definitely have been far more dangerous to Indian society.

The Shabri Kumbh Mela was not a debate on Christians or on conversions; neither was it a debate on Indian religions or secular forces. It was a defining moment for Indian society at large and whether fascist and fundamentalist forces would actually triumph. It was true that they managed to bring in their much flaunted numbers but as some tribals mentioned, “we just came here to have a good time !” It is true that they spewed venom and hate against Christianity but in doing so, they have only exposed their narrow, petty orientations. It is true they have decided to chalk out a strategy for change; hopefully, they will begin with themselves.

The three day programme has also thrown up several questions for which the likes of Modi and his cronies have to be held accountable. Among them are :

§ can and should Governments indulge in such wasteful expenditure in the name of religion, when millions of adivasis do not have access to the basic amenities of life ?

§ what provisions are there in the law to reign in those who continue to make inflammatory speeches, very specially directed against minorities and other vulnerable groups ?

§ article 25 of the Constitutions guarantees every single citizen, the right to freedom of religion; as the Constitutional Head of a Government, is Modi able to guarantee that to every single citizen in the State of Gujarat ?

In the run up to the Shabri Kumbh Mela, the organizers were caught on the back foot when confronted and went overboard in saying that the Shabri Kumbh Mela had nothing to do with Christianity or about re-conversions. The irony of it was that they seem to have had no other point on the agenda except Christianity and conversions. A huge banner summed up their agenda when it loudly proclaimed “Asia Khand mein Isai karan ko koi sthan nahi hai. Hindu dharm ke virodh mein jo koi karyarath hoinge ve sabh nasht hoinge (there is no place in the Asian Continent for Christianization. Whoever is involved in opposing the Hindu religion will be destroyed).

Some commentators feel that the Shabri Kumbh Mela was meant to be a rejuvenation of the Hindutva ideology in the country. But for many others and for the way the Shabri Kumbh Mela turned out, it could be Hindutva’s last gasp !